Skip to main content

Vaccine Beliefs and the Dunning-Kruger Effect

 

By now you have probably heard of the Dunning-Kruger Effect: A reliable finding across multiple domains of expertise, showing that experts on a topic know the limits of their own knowledge, but people who know only a little about it are unaware of their own limitations. This can also be stated in terms of a gap between one's competence in a topic area and one's confidence about it, with over-confidence being a typical characteristic of less-competent individuals. There is a slight tendency on the high end, as well, for experts to be overly pessimistic about their own performance, with their results on average tending to be slightly better than they give themselves credit for. The logical conclusion from this extensive body of knowledge is that one should probably evaluate people's expertise, rather than how confident they seem, in deciding whether to take them seriously or not.

The Dunning-Kruger effect is not enormous, by the way, even though it is statistically reliable. In popular culture, the effect has become exaggerated in the following type of diagram showing the process by which one develops expertise: Initially, confidence is shown to be near-infinite, in a peak that's dismissively labeled as "Mt. Stupid" on many charts. Then it is shown to fall abruptly into a "Valley of Despair," before finally increasing gradually on its way to a "Plateau of Competence." 

This may be an amusing image for PowerPoint talks, but it's not an accurate reflection of the true Dunning-Kruger effect established by research. As shown in the image at the top of the post, people only slightly over-estimate their own knowledge at the low end of expertise, and even their overconfident self-ratings are lower than the self-ratings of experts. It may indeed take a long time for the gradual development of expertise, but the new learner is neither so inept nor so deluded as the corporate-trainer version of this effect implies.

One area where the Dunning-Kruger effect has been referenced is in public-policy debates about vaccines. Vaccine hesitancy has been in the news again due to a major measles outbreak in Texas, New Mexico, and Oklahoma that has led to multiple deaths. The vast majority of cases have been in unvaccinated people, because the vaccine against measles is more than 95% effective in preventing disease. At the same time, however, new U.S. Secretary for Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy has been actively casting doubt on the efficacy of common vaccines, suggesting that the measles deaths were the result of poor lifestyle choices, that natural immunity from infection might be preferable to vaccination, nutritional supplementation with Vitamin A can help to prevent measles (side note that it cannot: Vitamin A can be useful in infected children who are malnourished, but should not be taken preventively because it builds up in the body with potentially toxic effects). U.S. health agencies have also recently cancelled grants on vaccine acceptance and on the development of new mRNA vaccines, and removed information about vaccines from Federal websites (you might note that for my source about the efficacy of the measles vaccine above, I used a Canadian health agency's website). Kennedy also recently ordered the CDC to conduct a review of potential links between vaccines and autism, even though that proposed link has been widely discredited based on extensive scientific research. (Kennedy cited one cherry-picked study to the contrary at his confirmation hearing; even that study has been strongly critiqued on methodological grounds).

In this climate of doubt, more people are likely to refuse vaccines for measles and other preventable diseases. A global study in 2022 found that one of the strongest predictors of COVID-19 vaccine refusal was a lack of trust for medical information provided by authorities, and in the U.S. this type of mistrust was directly tied to political affiliation. Kennedy himself was found to be one of the top 12 sources of COVID misinformation on the Internet in a 2021 report. However, the tone had already been set in 2020, when a Cornell University report found that 38% of all COVID-19 misinformation on the Internet came directly from President Trump. People with greater exposure to misinformation about COVID-19 and COVID vaccines then were more likely to refuse the vaccines, with a correlation of r = -.77 between accurate COVID-19 vaccine knowledge and vaccine refusal -- an extremely strong effect.

Let's circle back, then, to the Dunning-Kruger effect. Is the gap between expertise and confidence in one's conclusions a reasonable explanation for why people refuse vaccines? The studies above suggest that it is not. As with many behaviors, Intuitive Mind factors such as values and group affiliations seem to be much stronger predictors of vaccine acceptance than knowledge or confidence in one's expertise. Furthermore, the knowledge-confidence gap identified by Dunning and Kruger is actually much smaller than suggested by popularized versions of this finding, and low-expertise individuals are not really as overconfident you might have been led to believe.

This is a good thing. It means that in order to improve vaccine intake, we don't primarily need to persuade people. And in particular, we don't need to "break through" false confidence, or lecture people with facts. Instead, we need to build trust, to work within people's social networks, and to appeal to people's core values and beliefs. These are all functions of the Intuitive Mind. Ultimately, it should be no surprise that Intuitive-Mind mechanisms are the key to increasing vaccine acceptance. As Two Minds Theory suggests, it is the Intuitive Mind -- rather than logic and fact-based decision making -- that controls behavior. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What You Believe about Beliefs is Probably Wrong

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy  defines a "belief" as "the attitude we have, roughly, whenever we take something to be the case or regard it as true. ... Most contemporary philosophers characterize belief as a 'propositional attitude,' [where] propositions are generally taken to be whatever it is that sentences express. For example ... 'snow is white.'" Beliefs, then, (a) are expressed in language, (b) refer to some specific contents such as "snow," and (c) express some truth about those contents. The truth need not be an empirical statement about the world -- propositions such as "x is the square root of x-squared" are also beliefs under this definition even when there is no empirical referent for "x." Beliefs can be about a single thing, or about the relationships between things, in which case they might or might not be expressed as formal rules: e.g., "every bird has wings." Language, representation...

Some Things That AI Probably Shouldn't Do

  I'm on record endorsing the use of AI by students to improve the quality of their writing and their thinking, but also expressing concern about the potential for autonomous AI to end civilization! So what's the deal here? Am I for AI or against it? As in many areas of life, the answer is "it depends ...". In this blog post, I will look at some things that AI probably should not  be doing for us, which might help to delineate the areas in which it can be more beneficial. Let's start with ethics. Although some techno-futurists have argued that AI will eventually be better at knowing what's good for us than we are ourselves, a recent report showed that a "robo-ethicist" using large language models (LLM) showed notable flaws in its reasoning. LLMs' ethics were consistently more influenced by utilitarian thinking (do what causes the least harm or the most benefit in this specific situation) than by reasoning from first principles (Kant's id...

Will We Ever Be Able to Upload Our Consciousness to the Cloud?

It’s a popular sci-fi trope : The human consciousness now residing in a computer, trading physical life for machine-based immortality. In The Matrix this works both ways: You can not only upload your consciousness to a vast multiplayer online world, but also instantly download digitized knowledge from the cloud to your brain (“ I know kung fu! ”). A digitized consciousness might have some acknowledged limitations, sure – you don’t eat anymore, and you can’t smell the flowers. Even that seems ridiculous by modern technology standards, though: Couldn’t we design appropriate sensors, or simply simulate those experiences? Indeed, there’s a school of thought that claims we are already living in some type of simulated reality , whether computer-generated or otherwise. Let’s confine ourselves to currently existing digital technologies, and examine the question of whether it really might be possible to upload our consciousness to the cloud. China is investing a lot in brain-computer interf...