Skip to main content

New Evidence Supporting TMT as an Explanation for Type 1 Diabetes Self-Management Success


I have written previously about how the Intuitive Mind affects type 1 diabetes (T1D) self-management, for example based on people's situational awareness of changes in their own blood sugar as they occur. In one prior study, our team found that Intuitive-level variables such as motivation and social perception (based on a daily survey) were related to successful daily blood sugar control (based on time-in-range [TIR], a commonly used metric from continuous glucose monitoring [CGM]) among adolescents with T1D. I also wrote about my own experience trying a CGM for 2 weeks, which did seem to result in increased situational awareness. In another study, we found that adolescents' proactive use of a hybrid closed-loop system (pictured above), which incorporates an insulin pump and a dosing algorithm together with a CGM, resulted in better TIR results than when people waited for the technology to tell them what to do. Specifically, adolescents who looked at their CGM readout less often, and those who entered carbohydrate values to more accurately dose insulin with their meals, had better TIR results.

Our latest study with this population, now available online before print in a forthcoming issue of Health Psychology, combined both sensor and survey measures as potential predictors of T1D self-management. We again found that less interaction with the glucose pump was associated with better glucose control, and we replicated the finding that entering carbohydrates with a meal predicts better TIR. Both of these findings again suggest that the closed-loop system is most helpful when used in a proactive and situationally-aware way, versus a more reactive way where the user waits for alerts to know that something has gone wrong. In this study, we found that receiving more alerts was actually predictive of worse TIR results. 

A new feature of the latest study was that we asked people to fill out triggered surveys whenever they interacted with their insulin pump, in addition to a version of the single end-of-day survey about self-management that we had used in our prior survey research. These more intensive surveys allowed us to gather data about the reasons why people were interacting with their closed-loop system (which, if it works correctly, shouldn't require too much direct user interaction). We characterized a set of 11 different reasons into "proactive" and "reactive" categories. And consistent with our understanding of situational awareness in TMT, we found that the proactive interactions predicted better TIR. 

Many of the users' reasons for interacting with their closed-loop system had to do with a perception that their glucose level wasn't where it should be, which we allowed them to classify as "I think my blood sugar might be too high," "I think my blood sugar might be too low," or "I just feel 'off'." The perception that blood sugar was too high predicted better TIR. But by comparing to the CGM results collected at the same time as the survey, which we also had in this dataset, we discovered that participants were actually wrong most of the time about this risk -- they thought their blood sugar was too high, when it was still within the target range. Our interpretation is that people had learned some subtle bodily cues that allowed them to predict their blood sugar was likely to become too high in the near future. Because they then took action (e.g., giving themselves a bolus of insulin), the predicted spike in blood sugar never actually happened. This implies a level of situational awareness that can't be replicated by CGM monitors -- at least not yet! Maybe an AI program could learn these subtle cues in the same way that humans do, for a better future version of a closed-loop system that would automatically deliver more insulin at these times.

Overall, our findings in this latest study replicate some important results from our prior research on T1D self-management. They also extend the prior findings with a look at people's thought process in the moment when they are actually interacting with their insulin pump. Our findings were again consistent with TMT, in that an Intuitive-level awareness of one's own blood sugar seems to permit more focused and intentional interactions with the closed-loop system. People with diabetes still need to do some self-management, even with a closed-loop system that automatically delivers insulin when their glucose levels get too high. The key seems to be interacting with the device only at times when it is most appropriate and necessary, versus checking it all the time or never using it unless an alert message comes up. That kind of subtle "appropriateness" determination is something that our participants said they were making largely unconsciously (in a parallel qualitative study with these same participants). In other words, it's something that happens at the level of the Intuitive Mind.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What You Believe about Beliefs is Probably Wrong

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy  defines a "belief" as "the attitude we have, roughly, whenever we take something to be the case or regard it as true. ... Most contemporary philosophers characterize belief as a 'propositional attitude,' [where] propositions are generally taken to be whatever it is that sentences express. For example ... 'snow is white.'" Beliefs, then, (a) are expressed in language, (b) refer to some specific contents such as "snow," and (c) express some truth about those contents. The truth need not be an empirical statement about the world -- propositions such as "x is the square root of x-squared" are also beliefs under this definition even when there is no empirical referent for "x." Beliefs can be about a single thing, or about the relationships between things, in which case they might or might not be expressed as formal rules: e.g., "every bird has wings." Language, representation...

Some Things That AI Probably Shouldn't Do

  I'm on record endorsing the use of AI by students to improve the quality of their writing and their thinking, but also expressing concern about the potential for autonomous AI to end civilization! So what's the deal here? Am I for AI or against it? As in many areas of life, the answer is "it depends ...". In this blog post, I will look at some things that AI probably should not  be doing for us, which might help to delineate the areas in which it can be more beneficial. Let's start with ethics. Although some techno-futurists have argued that AI will eventually be better at knowing what's good for us than we are ourselves, a recent report showed that a "robo-ethicist" using large language models (LLM) showed notable flaws in its reasoning. LLMs' ethics were consistently more influenced by utilitarian thinking (do what causes the least harm or the most benefit in this specific situation) than by reasoning from first principles (Kant's id...

Will We Ever Be Able to Upload Our Consciousness to the Cloud?

It’s a popular sci-fi trope : The human consciousness now residing in a computer, trading physical life for machine-based immortality. In The Matrix this works both ways: You can not only upload your consciousness to a vast multiplayer online world, but also instantly download digitized knowledge from the cloud to your brain (“ I know kung fu! ”). A digitized consciousness might have some acknowledged limitations, sure – you don’t eat anymore, and you can’t smell the flowers. Even that seems ridiculous by modern technology standards, though: Couldn’t we design appropriate sensors, or simply simulate those experiences? Indeed, there’s a school of thought that claims we are already living in some type of simulated reality , whether computer-generated or otherwise. Let’s confine ourselves to currently existing digital technologies, and examine the question of whether it really might be possible to upload our consciousness to the cloud. China is investing a lot in brain-computer interf...